Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo
Udo Salters/Getty ImagesCraig Conover AND Paige DeSorbo broke up after three years of dating, but how did they go from thinking about an engagement to ending it?
“Craig was ready for the next steps and had plans to propose to Paige. He was really pushing for the next steps and wanted to settle down with her,” a source exclusively reveals Us Weeklynoting that living in different cities — DeSorbo, 32, lives in New York City while Conover, 35, resides in Charleston, South Carolina — made things difficult for the couple.
“Paige doesn’t want to move to Charleston, and logistically it would never work for long,” the insider explains. “A lot of their friends aren’t shocked at all, but they’re all sad for them.”
Despite the challenges of living apart, Conover felt confident about their future as a couple while speaking exclusively to us in October.
“I mean, we’ll get married one day,” he said Southern charm ssaid tar at the time. “But she’s a really career-driven person and she’s doing great. And I have a business that’s flying right now, so we’re making the best of ourselves before we officially come together as a team.”

Conover added that he and DeSorbo’s dynamic requires patience.
“We spend as much time as we can together and are patient with each other,” he said us. “But we’re in a great place, and fortunately, New York and Charleston are two great places to spend time. We just have to put in the work.”
Conover and DeSorbo have been long distance for their entire relationship. The pair met each other during the filming of season 1 of Winter house in 2021. They confirmed their romance that September while attending their wedding Summer house The costars Kyle Cooke AND Amanda butter. While the exes are “on good terms,” the source shares that “ending their relationship was long overdue.”
“They had been talking about their future for months,” says the insider. “They were hoping to make it through the holidays, but Paige felt a lot of pressure. Between them there were months that were rocky. Paige wanted to announce it because fans would notice that they weren’t together for New Year’s.”
DeSorbo announced the split during the Monday, Dec. 30 episode of her and Hannah Bernerthe Giggly Squad podcast.
“Craig and I have decided not to be together anymore,” she said. “I love him, I think he loves me. I think we will remain friends. Nobody did anything. It wasn’t a bad thing.”
DeSorbo added that the split was “the right decision for both of us” despite thinking Conover is “one of the nicest people I’ve ever met in my entire life.”
The source says that although DeSorbo and Conover’s split was “very cordial,” the pair are both “very sad” about it.
“Paige started the conversation, but they both agreed it wasn’t going to work. Craig was really emotional,” the insider shares. “There’s still a lot of love between them, but they just weren’t on the same page.”